Fake Amazon, FTC and CIA calls · New York · 2023
She Wrote About Money for a Living. One Afternoon of Calls Took $50,000 in a Shoebox
Charlotte Cowles is a personal finance columnist. On October 31, 2023, three fake callers walked her, one small step at a time, to handing a box of cash through a stranger's car window.
The short version
A fake Amazon agent passed her to a fake FTC investigator, who passed her to a fake CIA agent. They told her she was a suspect, told her not to call a lawyer, and had her withdraw about $50,000 in cash and hand it over outside her home. She realized it was a scam the same night.
It started with a normal-sounding call
The first caller said she was from Amazon customer service. Her name was “Krista,” and she said there was unusual activity on Cowles's account: about $8,000 spent on MacBooks and iPads.
Cowles could not find the purchase. Krista explained that it had been made through a business account. Cowles said she did not have one. Krista said she had two.
From there, the call moved from shopping to identity theft. Krista told her to check her credit cards. Cowles looked at her bank information and saw nothing unusual. Then Krista said Amazon was working with a liaison at the Federal Trade Commission, and offered to transfer the call. Cowles agreed.
That is the first quiet step in this kind of scam. Nothing has been asked for yet. The caller is only being helpful, and each small “yes” makes the next one easier.
The “FTC investigator” made her a suspect
The next voice belonged to “Calvin Mitchell,” who said he was an FTC investigator and gave a badge number. He asked Cowles to confirm her name, home address, birthday and the last four digits of her Social Security number.
Then the story turned frightening. He said accounts and property in her name were tied to large overseas wire transfers, to a car found near the Mexican border with drugs and blood in it, and to warrants in Maryland and Texas. He called her a suspect, and asked how much money she had. She told him about $80,000.
The FTC has since warned about exactly this script. In its words, the agency “doesn't have 'agents,'” and callers who give badge numbers and ID cards are impersonators whose goal is to get you to move money out of your account.
The “CIA agent” and the shoebox
Mitchell transferred her to a third man, “Michael Sarano,” who said he was with the CIA and also gave a badge number. He told her not to contact a lawyer. He told her to withdraw cash, and Cowles later estimated it at about $50,000.
She went to her bank and took out the money. Sarano told her to put it in a shoebox for an undercover agent. She argued, then agreed. Around 6 p.m. a car pulled up outside her home, and she put the box through the back window.
Later that night she realized what had happened. She told her husband and called the police. The police told her something worth remembering: the personal details the callers knew, like her address and part of her Social Security number, can be found or bought online. Knowing them proved nothing.
Cowles wrote about it in detail for New York magazine's The Cut, where she works as a personal finance columnist. A psychology professor quoted in coverage of her story described how scams like this work through small, step-by-step moves that pull people away from what they know to be true.
Why it worked on a careful person
Nothing about this scam needed Cowles to be careless. It used three things that work on almost anyone.
- A hand-off. Each caller vouched for the next. Amazon introduced the FTC, and the FTC introduced the CIA, so every new voice arrived with a reference.
- Fear and shame. Being told you are a suspect in a drug case makes you want to prove you are cooperating, quickly and quietly.
- Isolation. “Don't call a lawyer” removes the one person whose job is to say “stop.”
If it can happen to someone who writes about money every week, it can happen to anyone. That is why the useful question is not “who falls for this?” but “at which step can I stop it?”
Where it could have stopped
Looking back, there were several exits:
- At the transfer. Amazon does not hand customers over to the FTC by phone. Hanging up and calling Amazon through its own app would have ended it.
- At the badge number. A badge number spoken on the phone proves nothing. The FTC says it has no agents at all.
- At “don't call a lawyer.” No real investigator tells you to skip legal advice. That sentence alone is enough to hang up.
- At the bank. Taking out a large amount of cash is a moment to tell the teller what is going on. Tellers are trained to spot this.
The red flags
- A call about a big purchase you did not make
- Being transferred from a company to a government “agent”
- A badge number given over the phone
- Being told you are a suspect in a crime
- “Don't contact a lawyer” or “don't tell anyone”
- Any request to take out cash and hand it to someone
What to do if this happens to you
- Hang up. You can always call back on a number you look up yourself.
- If you are worried about an account, contact the company or your bank using the number on your statement or card, not the one the caller gave.
- Talk to someone you trust before you move any money, especially if the caller says it is serious or secret.
- If you already paid, call your bank and the police right away, and report it at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.
Sources
The facts of the case come from the news report listed first. Advice comes from the FTC and the FBI. Where a detail was not confirmed by police or a court, we say so in the story.
- Deseret News, report on the Charlotte Cowles case, February 16, 2024
- FTC consumer alert: No, FTC “agents” with badge numbers aren't calling you, May 27, 2025
- FTC: How To Avoid a Government Impersonation Scam
- FTC consumer alert: Business and government impersonators go after older adults' life savings, August 7, 2025
Last checked November 2, 2026.